Wholesome Bites NY: Cozy Gourmet Deli Near Barclays Center & Prospect Park 🥪🔥🎶

1. Store Overview 🏪

  • Name: Wholesome Bites NY

  • Address: 139 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217 📍

  • Phone Number: (917) 522-6619 ☎️

  • Operating Hours: Daily, 9 AM – 9 PM ⏰

  • Website: wholesomebitesny.dine.online 🌐

  • Main Services/Products: Bagels, deli sandwiches, smoothies, coffee, live music 🎵🥯🥤

  • Average Review Rating:

    • Google: ⭐ 4.776 (1000+ reviews)

    • Grubhub: ⭐ 4.9/5

    • DoorDash: ⭐ 4.8/5

2. First Impressions 👀

From the outside, Wholesome Bites NY blends in seamlessly with the charming brownstones of Park Slope, but the warm glow of its interior sets it apart. Inside, you're greeted with a surprisingly upscale deli vibe: rustic wooden shelves, a crackling fireplace, cozy seating, and low lighting perfect for winding down or catching up with a friend.

The ambiance is inviting and warm, accented by mellow tunes or even live acoustic sets on weekends. It’s not your average corner deli — it’s got Brooklyn soul with a gourmet twist.

3. Highlighted Menu Items or Products 🍽️

Popular Items (based on reviews & online orders):

  • Spicy Chicken Avocado Sandwich – $12.95

  • Berry Bliss Smoothie – $8.00

  • Everything Bagel with House Cream Cheese – $4.50

  • Grilled Veggie Panini – $11.00

  • Cold Brew Coffee – $4.25

💵 Price Range: $10–$20 per person
👍 Personal Pick: The Spicy Chicken Avocado Sandwich hits the sweet spot — toasted ciabatta, juicy chicken (pro tip: ask for extra sauce), and just the right kick.

4. Customer Reviews Summary 🗣️

What people love:
✅ “Delicious smoothies and sandwiches”
✅ “Wonderful staff”
✅ “Amazing customer service”
✅ “Perfect stop before or after the park”

Critiques to note:
⚠️ One reviewer mentioned the chicken was “dry and had no flavor” — though this was not echoed by many others.
⚠️ Limited seating during peak times

Overall, the service, quality, and vibe win big praise across all platforms.

5. Neighborhood Context and Nearby Landmarks 🌆

Located in Park Slope, Wholesome Bites NY is nestled among family-friendly boutiques, historic brownstones, and cultural hotspots.

Nearby Landmarks:

  • Barclays Center – 🏟️ Catch a Nets game or concert just a 12-min walk away.

  • Prospect Park – 🌳 Brooklyn’s backyard, perfect for a post-smoothie stroll or picnic.

  • Brooklyn Museum – 🖼️ Art, culture, and rotating exhibits about 10 mins away by transit.

Directions from Wholesome Bites NY:

  • To Barclays Center

    • 🚶 12 min walk via 5th Ave

    • 🚗 5 min drive (limited metered parking nearby)

    • 🚇 R train from Union St to Atlantic Av–Barclays Ctr (2 stops)

  • To Prospect Park

    • 🚶 15 min walk via Union St entrance

    • 🚗 6 min drive to Grand Army Plaza

    • 🚇 2/3 train from Bergen St to Grand Army Plaza (1 stop)

  • To Brooklyn Museum

    • 🚶 18 min walk

    • 🚗 7 min drive with nearby parking

    • 🚇 2/3 train to Eastern Parkway-Brooklyn Museum

6. Strengths and Weaknesses ⚖️

Strengths:
💪 Friendly service, live music, cozy vibe
💪 High-quality ingredients, generous portions
💪 Great smoothie and coffee selection

Weaknesses:
🤔 Small seating area – might be a challenge during lunch rush
🤔 A few mixed reviews on food consistency

7. Recommendations and Closing Remarks 📝

Wholesome Bites NY is a must-visit for anyone craving a cozy deli experience with a gourmet twist. Perfect for:

  • Remote workers looking for a calm cafe space ☕

  • Park visitors grabbing a bite after a long stroll 🌳

  • Music lovers enjoying the weekend live sets 🎶

Whether you’re just grabbing a smoothie to go or lingering by the fireplace with a sandwich and a song, this place has heart.

👉 I personally recommend trying the Spicy Chicken Avocado Sandwich and a Berry Bliss Smoothie! 😋

As the reviews suggest, Wholesome Bites NY is well-loved by locals for its warmth, flavor, and community vibe. 🏅